Border Collie is a breed that has stolen the hearts of many, with its intelligence, agility, and endless energy. They were specifically bred to herd sheep on the Anglo-Scottish border. Today they have become a favorite among dog owners who value their intelligence, trainability, agility, and high energy.
They are also known as the world’s smartest dog breed. You will immediately fall in love with their agile physique, smartness, and loyalty. However, just like any other breed they also have pros and cons. Border collies are highly devoted and loyal dogs, they can be a perfect companion for the right families, still, they require attention, care, and mental stimulation.
They need consistent training and socialization that can test your patience. So, before bringing a border collie into your life, understanding the Border Collie pros and cons is essential. So, let’s get started with the advantages and disadvantages of Border Collie.
Table of Contents
Border Collie Pros and Cons
Border collies are a popular breed, well known for their intelligence, loyalty, and agility. On one hand, they are loyal, devoted to their families, and always eager to learn. On the other hand, their constant energy needs direction. They need attention, care, and proper training to channel their energy, otherwise, they can be chaotic sometimes.
Border collies are a wonderful breed, and they are excellent watchdogs. This is a breed with which you can create a strong bond within days. However, they are extremely sensitive and can develop anxiety if not properly cared for. Moreover, their double coat requires proper grooming daily to prevent tangling and matting.
However, just like other breeds, Border Collies also come with their own set of pros and cons that potential owners should consider.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Highly intelligent and trainable | High energy requiring ample exercise |
| Excellent herding instincts | May exhibit herding behavior with children or other pets |
| Loyal and devoted | Requires mental stimulation and tasks |
| Versatile in various activities | May become bored and exhibit destructive behaviors if not mentally stimulated |
| Good watchdog | May be reserved or wary around strangers |
Border Collie Pros
Border collies offer much more rather than being intelligent and energetic. If you are a workout lover, they can be your companion too. So, If you are considering bringing a border collie into your family, you can look forward to the following benefits to help you decide.
Highly intelligent and trainable
Border collies are popular because of their intelligence. They are quick learners and respond well to training. They excel in activities like obedience, and agility.
Excellent herding instincts
They were specifically bred to herd sheep that’s why they possess excellent herding instincts. They can be a great asset for arms and ranches.
Loyal and devoted
Border collies are excellent companions. They are known for their loyalty and devotion. Moreover, they are always ready to protect you from any harm, making them great watchdogs.
Versatile in various activities
They are versatile in different activities such as obedience, herding, agility, frisbee, and many more. Furthermore, they need physical and mental stimulation to prevent boredom.
Good watchdog
Border Collies are highly alert and full of energy which makes them good watchdogs.
Border Collie Cons
Although Border Collies have commendable traits, they also have some cons that should considered before welcoming a collie into your family. Here are the 5 disadvantages of owning a border collie.
High energy
Border collies are very energetic. They need physical exercise and mental simulations to keep them healthy and happy.
Strong herding instincts
Their strong herding instincts can be problematic for other pets and children. Therefore, they need consistent training and socialization to avoid these behaviors.
Require mental stimulation
To prevent boredom and destructive behaviors, border collies need mental stimulation. If they are left unchecked, they can lead to chaotic behaviors like chewing, barking, or digging.
Prone to Boredom
Border collies are highly intelligent dogs and they need mental as well as physical stimulation. They need activities that keep them engaged, otherwise they will be bored.
Reserved around strangers
They can be wary or reserved around strangers. However, with consistent training and proper socialization, they can interact with people.
Who Should Own a Border Collie
You may be impressed by the benefits of Border Collie, but it’s better to pause and reflect. Border collies are not for everyone. This intelligent breed requires a specific type of owner to live with.
So, before making any decision consider these qualities. If you have these characteristics then you can be a great companion with Border Collies.
- Active Individuals
Active individuals or families who can provide outdoor activities, exercise, and playtime.
- Experienced Dog Owners
Border Collies are highly intelligent and need constant training. Experienced dog owners can be the best fit for them.
- People seeking a loyal companion
If you value loyalty and a protective nature, Border Collie would be a great addition to your family.
Who Should Not Own a Border Collie
Border Collies need attention, exercise, and mental as well as physical stimulation. They are skilled escape artists and require proper security. That’s why, They can not be a good choice for individuals having a laid-back lifestyle. Individuals having the following traits can not go for a Blue Heeler,
- Inactive individuals:
Border collies can not be a good fit for inactive individuals or people having tight schedules, because they require proper time and exercise.
- First-time dog owners:
First-time dog owners may struggle because of their independent nature and strong herding instincts.
- Those who do not want to deal with shedding:
During shedding season, Border Collies shed heavily. Moreover, they require daily grooming.
Border Collie Quiz
Is a Border Collie Right For Me?
If you are still confused with this question, should I get a border collie? Or not? Then this quiz is for you.
Personal Experiences from Our Reader
I have had my border Collie for 8 years. He is the smartest and most loyal dog. I trained him well. Last month there was someone who was trying to open my truck door, my dog barked right away and scared that person off. He is the best companion I’ve ever had.
Ben Schwatz
My first pet was a Border Collie. She was very smart, I loved training her. I taught her some amazing tricks. The exercise was not an issue with her. However, she was sensitive about socialization. She’s almost 8 now, extremely healthy, sweet, and well-trained. I love her company.
Ruby Mane
If you are a Border Collie owner, share your experiences with us. We’d love to hear yours.